Tuesday, August 20, 2013

The Self, part 1

If there is one concept which the spiritualists love to talk about, it is the "self" or the "ego" and how it is the cause of all that is wrong with the world.

Religions are against mostly pride and egoistical behavior whereas spiritualists decry the very feeling of being a self.

Spiritualists regard being oneself as an unmitigated evil which needs to be done away with.

According to spiritualists, being or feeling an individual causes humans to feel separate from each other and from the world; it causes violence and suffering; it causes the mind to play tricks with itself and with others; it causes greed, lust, desire, attachment, sorrow, and all the usual miasma of human interaction.

While in Hinduism, the aham (I) is asked to realize its unity with Brahman (God, see note), in Buddhism one is asked to realize that there is no individual self at all, and that it is all an illusion.  Buddhists claim that the "true nature" of everything, especially the self, is "Emptiness".

The fact of the matter is that all normal human beings do feel as individuals.  Such an extreme criticism of such a basic feeling as being oneself causes a not unsurprising effect: the mundane individual feels guilty and un-evolved when compared to the selfless ideal.  This guilt then expresses itself into all kinds of compensatory behavior: from submission to the guru, to giving money to godmen, to feeling depressed and helpless against this existential curse.

Feeling oneself to be an individual is supposed to cause all the normal human failings and thereby suffering.  On the other hand, being selfless (or being one with the "Self" with a capital S, God in other words) is supposed to end all suffering.  Selflessness is the end goal of human life, it is said.

If a person is told that he is wrong about a particular fact or feeling, one can still feel reasonably confident about one's mental faculties.  But if one is told that one is wrong even about what one is, that one's very being is a fraud perpetrated by unholy forces, there is not much ground left for one to stand on.

Then one is at the mercy of the guru or the scripture.  After all, if one is wrong about oneself, what could one be right about?

For the recorded human history, these statements of spiritualists and godmen have gone unchallenged because the field of developmental psychology was not yet advanced enough to answer this question: How does the feeling of "I" form and what is its nature?  What is the "self", after all?  How can we explain subjective consciousness or awareness as a phenomenon?

All we had as answers to this doubtlessly important question were stern proclamations and repetitions by stern faced godmen and their ilk.

(to be continued)

Note: God in Vedantic Hinduism refers to many kinds of entities.  There is Ishwara, the director of affairs.  Brahman is the very source of it all and is considered at a higher plane.  It is Brahman into which the self, the Atman, is to merge (or to realize its unity with).

Friday, August 16, 2013

The Investigation

Sherlock Holmes the philosopher-detective was investigating a serious crime.  The crime involved fraud, false advertising, peddling phony wares, and a possible murder of language.  The only evidence that he had for the crime was a bag full of books, written by people like J Krishnamurti, Osho and Deepak Chopra.

The investigation took him to the famous city of Time.

In the City of Time, there were three main areas of interest to Holmes: Time Boulevard, the Eternity Circle, and the Timeless Point.

His first stop was Time Boulevard, since it was the easiest to cover.  The street went in the east-west direction, with clear markers for each quarter-mile.  All the vehicles on that street moved at a constant speed, and there were no entry or exit streets and no stops or traffic lights either.  As the vehicles progressed on that street, their engines became noisier and noisier and the drivers' hair became grayer and grayer.  This street had no beginning and no end, as far as the eye could see.  Watson had once mischievously remarked to Holmes that the street did begin many billion miles to the west, but since there was no entry or exit, Holmes wondered how the vehicles entered that street so many billion miles ago.  It didn't make sense, and Watson started waving his hands in a rather singular manner when pressed.

There were a lot of interesting stuff happening on the Time Blvd, but Holmes was in a rush.  He wanted to get to the Eternity circle and took out his map of the town, as well as his pipe.

Difficulties were entering the picture.  The Eternity circle was there on the backside of the map as a name, but on the front side of the map it was nowhere to be found.  Oh finally he found it.  As the Time Blvd reached the edge of the map, there was a small sign there with an arrow titled "To Eternity".

Holmes was perplexed.  He called Watson on his cellphone (it was the 21st century after all): "If, as you say, the Time Blvd began some billions of miles ago, how far is eternity circle on this road?"  Watson chuckled on the other end and said, "No matter how far you go on this road, Eternity circle is always further down.  But some people, not wanting to go that far, consider Forever to be a good alternative destination.  That is just about a lifetime away.  I will be there for you forever, Holmes."

Holmes frowned as he blew a cloud of smoke in front of him.  He continued to walk along Time Boulevard, in deep contemplation.  Suddenly a rat or something similarly vile ran over his right foot and, startled, he froze.

As he did, he saw his pipe smoke mysteriously form itself into two words in the air "Timeless Point".  It was but for an instant, and the smoke vanished as soon as he noticed it.  He then looked to his side and noticed a billboard advertising a new show: "The Timeless Point Show!  Never Before seen, Never again.  Only now!  Come one, come all!!"

The billboard seemed to be pointing downward into a basement.  Holmes rushed towards it, thinking that the show might have ended.  But he was surprised to see that the show continued, only that it was a different show every moment, and yet intimately connected with the previous one.  No show was repeated, there was a slight difference every time, and it was hard if not impossible to pinpoint which show one had watched.

Holmes realized that his investigation was far from over, and that he needed more time to ponder over all this.  He slowly walked to his inn, and picked a random book by a German sounding author from his bag of books.  He anticipated trouble sleeping, and "Wittgenstein" seemed the most potent remedy to put one to sleep, he smilingly muttered.

He had read only a few pages of this weird little book and he drifted to blissful sleep.  As he did so, the book fell on the floor along with his cellphone.  The cellphone's only button clicked as it fell, taking a photo of the open page, and as his last call had been to Watson, it somehow sent a message with that photo to him.

Watson heard a loud "beep" on his phone.  Had Holmes solved the crime, after all?

He wasn't too sure, after he read the text on the photo that Holmes had sent:
"Death is not an event in life: we do not live to experience death. If we take eternity to mean not infinite temporal duration but timelessness, then eternal life belongs to those who live in the present." (Tractatus Logico-Philosophicus)
Perhaps, next day he would talk to Holmes.  It was confusing, but it was too late now.

The Four Noble Truths of the Buddha, part 3

Parts 1 and 2.

The Buddha's second noble truth ("There is the cause/origin of suffering")  is expounded in greater detail in other Buddhist sutras.  In its more detailed version, the Buddha goes into the causation of suffering over time.
The Buddhists call it the doctrine of "Dependent Origination", or Pratītyasamutpāda.

According to this doctrine, there are twelve stages through which Dukkha (or suffering) gets established.

Many of these twelve stages explicitly presuppose the doctrine of reincarnation.  Buddhists believe that sankharas or conditioned responses propagate through a non-material medium across many lives.

For a person who does not believe in reincarnation, the Buddhist explanation of suffering falls flat on its face.  The Buddha has very little to teach us if his explanation of suffering's origin is off the mark.  That is his central teaching.  The rest of Buddhist teaching is more about ethical behavior and about being careful and mindful in one's thought, speech and action.  Good advice without a doubt, but hardly earth-shattering.

The more one studies in depth the twelve stages as enumerated by the Buddhists, the more it becomes obvious that they were more interested in creating a theology and a formal structure of terms than to seek out any truth.  Buddhist teachings and sutras are known for highly formalized, repetitive statements.  They are good for chanting, but don't do a lot for elucidation or insight.

Consider this translated tract from the Mahasatipatthana Sutra:
Herein, monks, an aspirant when experiencing a pleasant feeling knows, "I experience a pleasant feeling"; when experiencing a painful feeling, one knows, "I experience a painful feeling"; when experiencing a neither-pleasant-nor-painful feeling," one knows, "I experience a neither-pleasant-nor-painful feeling." When experiencing a pleasant worldly feeling, one knows, "I experience a pleasant worldly feeling"; when experiencing a pleasant spiritual feeling, one knows, "I experience a pleasant spiritual feeling"; when experiencing a painful worldly feeling, one knows, "I experience a painful worldly feeling"; when experiencing a painful spiritual feeling, one knows, "I experience a painful spiritual feeling"; when experiencing a neither-pleasant-nor-painful worldly feeling, one knows, "I experience a neither-pleasant-nor-painful worldly feeling"; when experiencing a neither-pleasant-nor-painful spiritual feeling, one knows, "I experience a neither-pleasant-nor-painful spiritual feeling."
Thus one lives contemplating the physical senses internally, or one lives contemplating the physical senses externally, or one lives contemplating the physical senses internally and externally. One lives contemplating origination factors in feelings, or one lives contemplating dissolution factors in feelings, or one lives contemplating origination-and-dissolution factors in feelings. Or one's awareness is established with, "Sensation exists," to the extent necessary just for knowledge and awareness, and one lives detached, and clings to nothing in the world. Thus, monks, an aspirant lives contemplating the physical senses.
The third rung in the twelve rungs of Dependent Origination states that Consciousness leads to Name and Form (?).  Name and Form are not what is normally considered name and form, apparently, but the are supposed to refer to feeling, perception, intention, contact, and attention.  The fourth rung states that Name and Form lead to the six sense bases (?).  Really?
"And what [monks] is name-&-form? Feeling, perception, intention, contact, & attention: This is called name. The four great elements, and the form dependent on the four great elements: This is called form. This name & this form are, [monks], called name-&-form."
In Buddhism, to nip the chain of origination in the bud, one is supposed to attack Avidya (Ignorance) by becoming more and more aware of truth within and without.  But in practice, Buddhists typically start practicing one of the many Buddhist meditations based either on the Samatha or Vipassana cores.

Seeking knowledge or truth is a great pursuit, but I assert that any seeker who disregards the modern understanding of human behavior and plunges straight into an ancient meditation technique with an esoteric world view is not pursuing self-knowledge, but is after attaining a supposedly higher state of consciousness.

No philosopher in this age and day would find the fanciful spiritual conceptions and the obtuse taxonomy in Buddhism worthy of a serious response, but still we see many otherwise intelligent people regard Buddha as a great philosopher who elucidated the truth of suffering and pointed at a way out of it.

I think the reason for the recent popularity of Buddhism in urban educated classes is not hard to fathom.  It is that they have not studied Buddha's teachings at their source, or in depth, but have depended on hearsay.  Because they are themselves disenchanted with the world due to its stresses, and because they find enlightenment to be a worthy goal, and because they find their own religions and institutions to be hopelessly corrupt, Buddhism and the Buddha become their icons of "true spirituality" and "inner evolution".  The seemingly scientific and structured nature of Buddha's teachings give the impression that they are thoroughly modern and the correct results of painstaking research.  They are anything but.

As I have remarked in my other writings, I find Buddha's inquiry and search to be a great philosophical quest, but the results of his philosophical quest must be evaluated and questioned, not merely accepted or venerated.

Unquestioning veneration and scientific inquiry don't go hand-in-hand.  In fact, they are the exact opposites of each other.

Buddhist teachings, especially the noble eight-fold path, are simple on the surface.  But as soon as one goes below the surface, Buddhism reveals itself to be esoteric and non-obvious and presumptuous.

Buddhism is also known for discouraging "idle inquiry" and focusing more on practice and its results.  However, if Buddhist scriptures talk a lot of apparent philosophy in their primary sutras, then they open themselves up to scrutiny.  Moreover, any practice is built upon a bedrock of theory.  If the theory is suspect, what will the practice yield except a feel-good piousness and a practiced calm without understanding?

In the next part, I will focus on the third noble truth of the Buddha.

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Love at first sight

It is obvious that love at first sight happens only with people that one finds desirable.  That may seem too trivial to even express.  However, consider that the second part of the sentence contains the word "desirable" which is indicative of attraction, whereas the first part contains the word "love", which is likely to be considered a sacred feeling by those feeling it.

What I want to talk about is not the validity of "love at first sight", but its ramifications in the sexual marketplace.

Anyone who falls in love at first sight can will find, to their consternation, that they will be considered not very love-worthy.  It is rarely, if ever, that love at first sight succeeds in leading to a long-term relationship.

People fall in love with what they consider attractive or desirable.  Attraction leads to a relationship only if one doesn't feel like one is selling oneself short.

Consider a hypothetical male and female: Jake and Kate.  Jake has fallen in love with Kate at first sight.  And consider that there is Adam also in the mix, who is presumably not yet in love with Kate but equally attractive at first glance, compared to Jake.

Jake expresses his love to Kate impulsively.  Adam stays aloof.

Here is how the hind-brain of Kate will churn:  "Someone who falls in love with me is a "fish" already in the "net".  I have that anyway.  Now the question is that whether that man is good enough for me so that I don't have to regret it later.  Jake is saying that he fell in love with me at first sight.  That is cute and flattering but really bad for his long-term prospects.  I didn't even have to woo him or even be seductive towards him and he is already in the net.  Looks like I can do much better than him.  After all, I got Jake without any effort.  If I put in some effort, may be I can get someone better than him.  Adam hasn't fallen in love with me yet.  Does it mean that he thinks I am not very attractive for him?  That means he is looking for a more attractive girl than me.  That means if I get him, it will be a good deal for me.  That means, that I should ignore Jake and go after Adam."

It is a conundrum, but an entirely logical one: Kate likes the fact that Jake loves him, but Kate dislikes the ease with which Jake loves her.  An easy love is an easily ignored love.

To admit that one loves someone at "first sight" is flattering to them, but insulting to oneself.  Even if one doesn't realize it oneself, the other will.

Living from the Heart

Living "from the heart" is the message of many a new age wave.  Another phrase for this is being "true to oneself".

Before one starts being true to one's heart, it might be useful to see what the heart contains, and how it came to be that way.  The easiest way to do this is to look at an infant, as yet unsocialized and uncivilized, and who is living completely from the heart.  Because it is not capable of living any other way.

The infant lives for its needs and wants, and does not care about others' feelings, expectations, moods, or anything other than its own interests.  For an infant, the universe pretty much revolves around itself.  Not that the infant is being a prick, its brain has not yet developed to feel anything other than its own needs and wants.

Developmental psychologists generally agree that the recognition of other human beings as conscious and subjective entities happens at a certain stage, and is not there in the first few years of an infant's life.  During those first few years, the infant regards others in its perceptual field as provider entities or familiar entities or likable or unlikable entities, but not entities who need to be thought about or cared about.

An infant is an inconsiderate human being.

An infant is also, it so happens, living from the heart and being true to itself.  It is easy to do so for the infant, since consideration of others does not (can not) enter the picture.  The infant can cry loudly when it feels hungry or wet, and can sleep when it wants, and throw away what it does not like, and grab onto what it does like (even if it belongs to someone else, or even if it is someone else, say a bunch of hair).

To do what one feels like is the same as being inconsiderate or indifferent to others.  For an infant, that is expected behavior and for it, everything is forgiven.  After all, it doesn't know any better than to be a selfish, inconsiderate "prick".

Similarly, an infant is true to itself because not only does it not know any other way (civilization is, if nothing else, being untrue to oneself) there are no consequences for it to be that way.  It has no reason to be untrue to itself.  And its acting in a supremely selfish manner is what everybody expects.  There is no punishment for an infant to do just what it wants to do at some moment.  There is no expectation of civility, or decorum, or restraint, or delayed gratification, et al. from an infant.  Perhaps, when it is slightly older and when we expect it to use its mind and not be so mindless.

Mindfulness needs a mind, which is still unformed in an infant.

Not only is an infant oblivious to others, it is oblivious to cause and effect, and to the consequences of its actions.

It is a capital mistake, if you are an adult, to try to live as an infant.  Not only are there expectations from you, which obviously you resent, but there are severe consequences if you reject those expectations and start living from the heart and being true to yourself. More than anything, you are supposed to know that there is something called cause and effect.

There is also an additional complication, which I hinted at near the beginning of my article.  Sometimes it may not be clear as to what the heart is saying, or what being true to oneself entails.

Let me provide a few, elementary, examples:
  1. You like something in a shop window.  Try to grab it without paying for it and yo will go to jail.  The heart wants it, but the heart also doesn't want to go to jail.  Which heart to listen to?
  2. You feel an intense attraction to a person of the opposite sex walking on the street and want to do something unholy then and there. The heart wants it, but the heart also doesn't want approbation and misdemeanor (if not rape) charges and the effort of arranging a bail bond.  Which heart to listen to?
  3. You feel an intense urge to eat a large tub of icecream. The heart wants it, but the heart is also afraid of the gain in body weight and all that it will unfortunately entail.
Civilization is the very name of this complexity.  To be civilized is to accept that there are unfulfilled desires of the heart because one needs to be considerate of others.  To be fair to libertines, society doth sometime intrude too much into the private cavorting of two consenting adults, especially in less developed societies.  But nobody would disagree that social sanction and the legal process, though at times over-reactive, does more good than harm.  We want there to be laws and punishment for those who break those laws.  We want there to be acceptable forms of behavior when we go to a public place.  We want people to behave themselves according to the situation, and so on.
An adult who finds the burden of civilization and its discontents too weighty can be forgiven for wanting to live "free as a bird", with a "song in heart", always "true to oneself" and "beholden to no one".  
But as I said, that would be a capital mistake.
Not only is an adult's heart a complex organ, with conflicting desires and fears.  An adult would come across swift correcting action from others if its acts violate or offend others' rights or expectations.
Not only the expression of positive or accumulative desires, but the expressions of sadness and anger are also severely limited in modern society.  An adult crying or wailing loudly will attract a lot of, perhaps unwanted, attention.  An adult throwing a tantrum by banging the table or throwing away food will get a stern feedback rather quickly, in addition to the bill.
The question people forget to ask when they advise others to live from the heart or true to themselves is this:  Why does an adult not live from the heart in the first place?  If the advice is good and practical, then what is the reason that this advice even needs to be given?
The reason adults do not live from their heart is simply because they are adults and have to think of others as well.
It is quite true that sometimes this thinking about how others would react can become overpowering, can lead to bullying or emotional blackmail from others, and inhibit action which would be natural, healthy and sane.
As long as society has existed, neurosis has co-existed with it.  Too much thinking about how others would react can lead to a kind of resentful paralysis.  There are always emotional bullies who take advantage of the less assertive by expecting too much from them and getting all angry or irritated if others do not do as per their bidding.
Or if someone is too afraid of expressing even adult desires, then such a situation definitely calls for some strong advice.  "Grow a pair" might be a better phrasing than "be true to yourself" in such cases.
I characterize these repressive situations as forced adolescence.  As an infant, you are expected to care little for others and all is taken care of for you.  As an adolescent, you are supposed to make decisions only with the concurrence of your parents who then support you if the decision goes bad.  And as an adult, you are supposed to make your own decisions and suffer the consequences yourself.
If an adult is not being socially or emotionally allowed to make his own decisions, then such a society is a repressive society forcing adolescence on its citizens.  In such a society, a bit of "living from the heart" or "being true to oneself" advice can provide some courage and confidence to a timid adult, if the decision is otherwise a matter of personal choice and is not hurting anybody.
But there will be consequences even there: hurt feelings of those who profess to "care for one", perhaps some social ostracizing, etc.  But in a repressive society, sometimes a little rebellion goes a long way in blazing trails for others to follow.
In some life choices, being true to oneself can mean doing what is emotionally more satisfying than what is more expedient or prudent or monetarily fulfilling.  Becoming an artist rather than a clerk, if the choice truly exists, might call for some heartfelt decision making.
I find that the sign of a healthy adult in a healthy society is that his doing what "feels" right makes him feels good, and makes others feel good as well.  In such a society, an adult will not need exceptional courage to do what his heart is telling him, and his heart will not tell him to do stupid or harmful things in the first place.
There will always be some resentment or unfulfilment as long as there is a tension between the individual and the society, and as long as individual desires are conflicted within.  
To continue to lessen this tension and conflict should be the goal of individual and social intervention.