Saturday, August 10, 2013

A Response to "Was the Buddha a pessimist, by S N Goenka"

Mr S N Goenka, of Goenka Vipassana fame, has written a long essay claiming that Buddha was not a pessimist.  The essay was originally written in Hindi, but has been translated into English and is available in its entirety here.

The essay is quite long and meandering and does not possess a formal structure for it to be formally reviewed and analyzed.

Before reviewing and commenting on Mr Goenka's essay, some general comments: After regarding the length of the essay, one could be forgiven for assuming that there must be good reasons for many people to consider the Buddha a pessimist.  As an analogy, if the defense statement in a trial is very long, it stands to reason that the prosecution must have some evidence or persuasive power.

Secondly, the essay has cherry-picked incidents and sutras of the Buddha which purportedly show him to be not a pessimist.  There are grave examples in Buddhist texts (for example the Nine Cemetery Observations section in the Satipatthana Sutta) which show the contrary.  Be that as it may, I think even in these incidents and sutras there is ample expression and illustration of why Buddha can still be considered a a non-votary of happy living on earth.

Thirdly, I recognize that Mr Goenka is not a rigorous intellectual and his writings are meant to be emotionally persuasive, and he perhaps is not willing to question the basic tenets of Buddhism.  His acceptance of Buddhist texts is no less than veneration.

Now, on to some brief comments about the essay.

In the section "Ultimate Truth", Mr Goenka states that for the Buddha, "the four Noble Truths lead to the ultimate reality of nibbāna, which is beyond the senses: eternal, everlasting and permanent."

This statement is the key to understanding the aim of Buddhism (which is similar to the aim of all spiritual disciplines): to escape this world (the world of senses, people, time and space) and to somehow experience or dwell in the other world (the world of senselessness, timelessness and spacelessness).  This world is the plane of misery, and that world is the plane of bliss.  This world is the plane where there is craving, aversion, suffering, birth and death; and that world is where there is only absolute bliss.

The Buddha is quite explicit about it:
‘There is that dimension where there is neither earth, nor water, nor fire, nor wind; ... neither this world, nor the next world, nor sun, nor moon. And there, I say, there is neither coming, nor going, nor stasis; neither passing away nor arising: without stance, without foundation, without support. This, just this, is the end of dukkha’. (Udana 8.1; PTS: viii.1; Nibbana Sutta).
It is clear that the Buddha is advocating not a modulation or management or lessening of one's suffering or stress or sorrow while living on earth; his only solution is to proceed towards experiencing a timeless, space-less realm.

Further down, in the section "Does a doctor promote disease?", Mr Goenka writes:
An expert doctor comes to examine a sick person. He explains to the sick person: "This is your disease; this is the cause of your disease; and here—I have a medicine for your disease. The medicine will remove the cause of the disease and thus cure the disease." The sick person takes the medicine and becomes healthy. Now, can we say that this doctor is promoting disease or promoting health?
The criticism of the Buddha is not that he is promoting suffering, but that he is seeing life on earth as nothing but suffering and that the only worthwhile endeavor according to him is to not be born again.  The "medicine" that the Buddha offers the suffering person is of a curious kind, viz, to be completely detached from this world and its happenings, to not let anything affect or bind oneself.  In effect, Buddha is not being a doctor at all.  He is claiming that there is actually no cure in this world, and the only cure is to leave this world and its miseries behind.  As an analogy, it is as if a patient goes to the doctor to get relief from toothache, and the doctor removes his jaw altogether.  No teeth, no toothache, the doctor happily proclaims.

A little further, Mr Goenka writes:
Every serious meditator experiences that the entire field of the cycle of birth and death is misery. However, most importantly, one also knows that there is a way out of this misery. How wrong it is to call the Buddha a preacher of misery when he has actually given us a way out of all misery!
Nobody is calling the Buddha a preacher of misery, Mr Goenka.  He has been called a pessimist because he, like you, saw only misery in this "entire field of the cycle of birth and death".

I am inclined to think that Mr Goenka, in his zeal to defend the Buddha, is attacking straw-man arguments.  For example:
From the assertion that his philosophy and teachings were nothing but suffering and misery, the implication is that the Buddha himself was miserable and unhappy.
Nobody is asserting is that his philosophy and teachings were "nothing but suffering and misery".  The claim is that his teachings see only misery in this life, and offer the solution which is to escape to a birth-less/death-less realm.

In the section "Happiness even for householders", the advice quoted as given by the Buddha ("obey your parents", "keep standing when elders are standing", "be moral", "remain content", "abstain from evil", etc.) is embarrassingly pedestrian, unquestioning, and timid.  Even so, this is not really Buddha's main teaching.  The crux of Buddha's solution to the problem of human suffering is to attain Nirvana and to never be born again.

In the section "Use of the term sukha (Happiness)", the Buddha is very explicit in stating that happiness in the "other" world is to be preferred over the the happiness in "this" world:
1. Happiness of home and happiness of homelessness (of a monk or a nun)—between the two, the happiness of homelessness is greater.

2. Happiness of sensual pleasures and happiness of renunciation—between the two, the happiness of renunciation is greater. 
3. Happiness of various realms and happiness beyond all the realms of existence—between the two, the happiness beyond the realms of existence is greater.
The section on "Overemphasis on misery" is quite interesting.  Mr Goenka compares the Buddha's aphoristic statements on misery with the descriptive ones in Vishnu Purana and comes to the conclusion that if there is to be blaming and shaming, then Vishnu Purana is the worse offender.  I find the section on the suffering of birth quite hilarious.  That Mr Goenka agrees with the Vishnu Purana statements is quite telling.

...

In summary, I find that Mr Goenka has not fully understood the criticism against the Buddhist teachings and has therefore offered a meandering and weak defense.  The Buddha is in-line with other eastern spiritual traditions in offering an out-of-this-world solution to the problem of suffering.  To be fair, the Buddha only emphasized and verbalized the aspect of misery more, but all eastern spiritual traditions regard life on earth as sorrowful, secondary and preparatory for a blissful life elsewhere.  

If one really listens to spiritual philosophy, life is best avoided.  They only differ in the "How" aspect.

Friday, August 09, 2013

The Four Noble Truths of the Buddha, part 2


The second noble truth of the Buddha describes the "origin of suffering" as follows (from Samyutta Nikaya LVI, 11)
What is the Noble Truth of the Origin of Suffering?
It is craving which renews being and is accompanied by relish and lust, relishing this and that: in other words, craving for sensual desires, craving for being, craving for non-being. But whereon does this craving arise and flourish? Wherever there is what seems lovable and gratifying, thereon it arises and flourishes.
There is this Noble Truth of the Origin of Suffering:such was the vision, insight, wisdom, knowing and light that arose in me about things not heard before.
The Buddha describes three kinds of cravings, or desires, that he considers the origin of suffering: craving for sensual pleasures, craving for being something, or craving for not being something.

If suffering is to be considered anxiety and frustration about desires related to oneself, then perhaps these three categories suffice.

But there are many more kinds of cravings, not easily classified as the above three.  The desire to see justice done, the desire for a better world, the desire to see someone change, the desire to discover s solution to a problem, the desire to bring order from chaos, and so on and so forth.  All of these can and do lead to suffering.

"I want to sense", "I want to be" and "I want to not be" are desires related to one's senses and one's ego.  Is the second noble truth wide enough to encompass all desires which can lead to suffering?

We are not yet discussing what aspect of desire leads to suffering.  Whether it is the process of fulfilling that desire or whether it is the non-fulfillment of the desire.

I think pursuing a goal can be considered stressful, and the non-achievement of a desire can be considered frustration.  Some of these stresses and frustrations can be quite intense and cause a great deal of turmoil.

If any stress is to be considered suffering which is to be avoided, then of course having no desires is the solution, which Buddha indeed advocates.

Desire is simply psychological energy aimed at a achieving a state of affairs.  The absence of desire means an absence of psychological drive.  It is to have a vehicle (a body and the mind) and no destination to drive to (no goal).  If the aim of human life is to finally become aimless, then this philosophy makes eminent sense.  But if the aim of human life is something else, then this philosophy is an invitation to apathy, dysfunction and de-motivation.

People claim that spirituality is not dysfunctional, that spiritual people engage in all kinds of good deeds to help others.  Gurus in India are known to patronize charitable hospitals and schools.

There are a few problems with this claim.

The first problem is that a desire to help others is nevertheless a desire, and spiritually speaking it has as much potential for suffering as anything else.

The second problem is that desires and their fulfillment can lead to opportunities and the creation of space for subtler and higher states of being.  Hence, trying to be rid of desires altogether can lead not to desire-less-ness, but resentment.

Even in Buddhism there is the concept of a Bodhisattva, who delays his own nirvana to help others come closer to nirvana.  Even the Buddha, after (presumably) attaining Nirvana, did not die but spent the rest of his life teaching others.

Hence, even in Buddhism, desire and its resultant suffering is admissible if it serves a great cause.  I claim that most human desires are for better states of affairs for oneself, one's loved ones or for one's community.  It is arguable that these wished-for states of affairs (less poverty, more justice, less inflation, better health, better safety) can lead to more opportunities for people to become more evolved.  In a war-torn African country, the possibilities for psychological evolution are fewer than in, say, Iceland.

If we consider the hierarchy of needs (such as propounded by Maslow, among others) as valid, then it is clear that any kind of fulfillment, even for social recognition or for love, enables one to feel fulfilled at that level and paves the way for "higher" kinds of achievements.

Therefore, someone wanting a good meal for their family, or being anxious to find a good spouse, or being concerned about one's reputation, can be considered desires to achieve a state of affairs where one can feel enabled to find higher or subtler kinds of fulfillment.

Subtler itches are felt only when the grosser ones have been scratched.

Hence, any person, and not just the spiritual teachers, can justify his activities as an expression of his desire to achieve better well-being.

The third problem is more sociological than philosophical: most such charitable activities are done with non-spiritual reasons (tax rebates, providing jobs to the faithful, gaining goodwill from the community, gaining real estate at cheap rates, building a heritage and a name for the guru/ashram, etc.) and in any case, are funded with the community's money in the first place.

There are numerous problems with the what the second noble truth is claiming: the very notion of considering desires as the origin of suffering, and therefore something to be rid of.

The first problem is that if one takes the Buddha seriously, there is absolutely no way not to make spiritual enlighenment itself into a goal, and to therefore desire it.  And to thereby go through the cycle of agony, competition, recognition, frustration, etc.  Too many Buddhist teachers have warned against the tendency of making spiritual enlightenment a personal ambition.  But to me, there is no other possibility.  The whole focus of a spiritual seeker, or a monk, is to gain in wisdom, to become liberated, to attain nirvana.  These are all desires squarely falling in the "craving to be" category.

Hence, there is a logical problem with desiring desirelessness.  Desiring only desirelessness and then not even that, or talking about throwing away the ladder after one has climbed it etc., are highly dangerous approaches because they assume the end-state is real.  These approaches need to have a lot of faith in what Buddha has claimed about Nirvana.  If for some reason (and there are a lot of good reasons) the goal is imaginary, or the pursuit is misguided, or if the path is wrong, or if the application of teachings is incorrect, then not only is one completely worthless in the real world (having no desire there), but is also wasting one's time and energy in running after a mirage.

The second problem is that desire is emotional energy and to see desires as evil, and to not want to desire at all is to kill one's emotional core.  Sincere spiritualists, by means subtle or gross, try to get rid of their emotional responses because to express emotions is to confess desire.  Even here there is some dishonesty involved.  It is considered permissible to feel "good" feelings and desires even while on the spiritual path.  Compassion and gratitude, for example, are actively encouraged even in Buddhism.  After a while on the spiritual path, one's emotional responses are subject to approval by the spiritual texts or the authority figures, and one is well on one's way to a lack of emotional autonomy.

The third problem, and the most serious I think, with considering desire as the cause of suffering and stopping there, is to completely brush aside the etiology and evolutionary explanation of desire.  Admittedly, evolutionary psychology wasn't there as a discipline when Buddha was alive.  Darwin hadn't been born yet.

Human desire and the human mind is a complex system with some influences which reach back millions of years.  To not inquire into those influences, at least now when there is research available, and to point at a mystical non-self-realization as the root cause of human suffering, because the Buddha said so two thousand years ago, is intellectual laziness.

For example, why do humans crave sensual pleasure?  Is it just due to ignorance, as the Buddha says?  Hardly.

Why do humans crave recognition, or prosperity?  Is it due to ignorance, as the Buddha says?  Not really.

Why do humans engage in territorial and tribal disputes?  Could it be because we, like all other species, want better prospects for our genes?

How come there is this sense of "self" or the "ego"?  I think Daniel Dennett has made some interesting points in the last few years which go deeper into this than just claiming that it is due to "ignorance".

It is not the Buddha's fault that research into consciousness and the "self" had not matured in those days.  It is still considered a developing field.  But what is remarkable is the humble arrogance of the Buddhist claim that they have figured out the origin of desire and of the sense of "self", and that it is "ignorance" of one's "true nature" which the Buddhists know to be "empty".

I want to quote Richard Dawkins here:
Intelligent life on a planet comes of age when it first works out the reason for its own existence. If superior creatures from space ever visit earth, the first question they will ask, in order to
assess the level of our civilization, is: 'Have they discovered evolution yet?' Living organisms had existed on earth, without ever knowing why, for over three thousand million years before the truth finally dawned on one of them. His name was Charles Darwin. To he
fair, others had had inklings of the truth, but it was Darwin who first put together a coherent and tenable account of why we exist. Darwin made it possible for us to give a sensible answer to the curious child whose question heads this chapter. We no longer have to resort to superstition when faced with the deep problems: Is there a meaning to life? What are we for? What is man? After posing the last of these questions, the eminent zoologist G. G. Simpson put it thus: 'The point I want to make now is that all attempts to answer that question before 1859 are worthless and that we will be better off if we ignore them completely.' (The Selfish Gene) 
(to be continued) 

Thursday, August 08, 2013

The Four Noble Truths of the Buddha, part 1

The First Truth (as taken from the primary Sutra first explaining the four noble truths: the Dhammacakkappavattana Sutta):
Suffering, as a noble truth, is this: Birth is suffering, aging is suffering, sickness is suffering, death is suffering, sorrow and lamentation, pain, grief and despair are suffering; association with the loathed is suffering, dissociation from the loved is suffering, not to get what one wants is suffering — in short, suffering is the five categories of clinging objects.
The Buddha defines the five categories of clinging objects, or the five clinging aggregates as these:
  1. Material form
  2. Feelings
  3. Perceptions
  4. Mental formations
  5. Consciousness
A modern psychiatrist will see the description of the first noble truth as an expression of a depressed state of mind.

Let's start analyzing what the Buddha said, or supposedly said.

...

Why is birth suffering?  Yes, the infant cries and the process of labor can be quite painful.  But is that enough to call birth "suffering"?

Birthdays, especially the event of birth, are celebrated in communities all over the world.  Parents are congratulated for the birth of their child.  In general, parents, grandparents, family and friends feel genuinely and exceedingly happy at a birth event.  People look forward to this event.  Couples having difficulty conceiving spend huge amounts of money to have a baby.

All these point to the fact that birth is a desirable event for most people.  And yet, the Buddha calls it suffering.  Why?

During the ten-day Goenka Vipassana discourses, Mr S N Goenka claims birth is suffering because the child is stuck in the womb for a long time, and because the child screams as soon as it is born.  When somebody (in Mr Goenka's own words) explained to him that the screams may be the child's attempt to breathe on its own for the first time, Mr Goenka smirked and claimed that the desire for oxygen was a precursor for all other desires and so now the process of suffering had begun.  It can sound quite convincing to people who already find their lives woeful and are just looking to validate a negative and pessimistic outlook towards life.

If the Buddha meant that birth is suffering because it is the start of degeneration, then perhaps an expectation of non-degeneration is to blame.  Even so, by all accounts, an infant grows in health, intelligence and strength for the first twenty five years of its life.  After that time, perhaps, one can say that one is over the hill.  But how can birth be suffering?

...

Why is aging suffering?  It can mean more wisdom, more experiences, more opportunities to do what one could not do earlier.  After forty or fifty years, the body might need some care and medical help.  And yes, one is closer to death, which not many people consider wholesome.  Is that a justification to consider aging suffering?  To some extent, perhaps.

Why is aging suffering?  Is it because one expected to be forever young, or immortal?  Was that a reasonable expectation, or a neurotic one?

...

Sickness is indeed suffering.  Not many people will dispute that.  However, it is usually temporary and most ailments are now treatable, given advances in the medicinal sciences.  Analgesia (management of pain) is a full-fledged discipline in modern medicine to help diminish the painful effects of illness.

Notably however, for most people, periods of good health far outnumber periods of sickness.  By any account, most people are living longer, healthier lives in today's world than ever before.  Yes, sickness is something to avoid, but it is notable that the Buddha doesn't mention the joy of good health (having a good meal, taking part in an invigorating physical activity, having good digestion, and so on), but focuses on the "sickness is suffering" part.

...

Death is suffering, indeed.  However, death is the ending of life.  If death is to be considered suffering (as it is), then life cannot be.  

As an analogy, if Mr Maugham disliked the fact that dinner was ending, then he must have enjoyed it.

...

Sorrow, lamentation, pain and grief are other words for suffering (or for expressions of suffering), so the Buddha doesn't win any points for saying something deep.

It is true that life contains sorrow as well as joy.  And if joy inevitably gives way to sorrow, it is equally true that no sorrow lasts forever.  Time heals, the intensity of an ache or of a loss diminishes, a depression lessens in force, and one is able to again enjoy the pleasures that life has to offer.

...

Association with the loathed is suffering.  True, it can be irritating and somewhat boring.  But "suffering" is a rather strong word for this quibble.  Why loathe others in the first place?   Why not just recognize that people have their own agendas and levels of evolution and be defensive against their overtures or invitations?

One must keep in mind that the Buddha is not advocating being selective about one's company.  A few sentences forward in his discourse, and we will read him advocate a rather extreme solution to this nagging problem of human socializing.

...

Dissociation from the loved is suffering.  That does mean that association with them was pleasurable and desirable.

...

Not to get what one wants is suffering.  Yes, but if one is an adult, one admits a temporary defeat and then again pursues another goal, or the same one in a different way.

...

We have come to an end of a selective listing of the what Buddha considers the unwanted aspects of normal living.

The first noble truth is neither noble, nor true.  It is a pessimistic look at life as a plane of sorrow, and is a rejection of fulfillment and happiness in "worldly" life.

In my opinion, the Buddha is saying: Life is suffering because every joy, every pleasure, every good thing, comes to an end, and then one is again to strive.  That there is no "happily ever after."  And that therefore, there is no "happy now-and-then".

The above phrasing (if correct) and the Buddha's list of five clinging aggregates, and classifying them as suffering, is to look at life as a burden and as a journey of pain and little else.

If not for the belief in reincarnation, and if not for a belief in transcendence-over-the-span-of-many-lives, I do not know why a Buddhist wouldn't just commit suicide.

If the apocryphal story about Buddha not being allowed out of the palace, and then one day seeing an old man, a sick man and a dying/dead man and then being shocked into a journey towards "self-realization" is true, then a modern psychologist would characterize it as a severe maladjustment born of unrealistic expectations and of a heavily sheltered upbringing.

Though I do think that the story is almost certainly false.  There is no way a man can grow to his late twenties and not know that there is aging, disease and death.  What was the psychopathology of the start of Buddha's journey?  I don't think there has been worthwhile research in that.  Hagiography is not biography.

The first noble truth, that "There is suffering" is not only unremarkable (everybody knows life contains its measure of sorrow), the fact that it doesn't proclaim the joy of life inspires little confidence in it being an expression of a balanced mind.

There are two possibilities about what Buddha is saying in the first noble truth: a) That life contains suffering, b) That life is nothing but suffering.

(a) is obviously true, and therefore a trite observation.  (b) is obviously false.

Tuesday, August 06, 2013

Why Not Live in the Present


  1. Human beings have the capacity to remember and learn from the past, and to anticipate and plan for the future.

  2. Human beings are rational as well as emotional.  Our memories are of data as well as of feelings.  A memory of having had an ankle sprain can make us walk more carefully on an uneven surface.  This "carefulness" coexists with a mild anxiety.

  3. Emotions and feelings are rough-and-ready mental responses to situations.  They may be imperfect, but they evolved to serve a purpose, and they do serve a purpose.  That purpose is: to steer us towards behavior which has over the millenia proved to be advantageous for our genes.

  4. One of the fundamental qualities of a human adult is his/her capacity to delay pleasure, or to plan for pleasure while engaging in relatively less pleasant activities.  Delayed Gratification, in other words.  Instant Gratification cannot lead to outcomes which require planning, drudgery and boredom.

  5. Being comfortable with Delayed Gratification is a mark of adulthood.

  6. Due to various reasons, some humans might be maladjusted and will not find it easy to delay their gratifications and work towards meaningful goals which provide long-term fulfillment.  A modern malady of this ilk is the Attention Deficit Disorder.

  7. These human beings, who are not able to patiently endure boredom or drudgery, can be said to be living in an infantile state of mental effort-reward cycles with a fast turn-around time.

  8. This burden of being human has led to untold benefits in terms of our survival advantage over other species, and our prosperity and progress.  Of course, there is the grave risk that we might be exhausting the planet with our insatiable appetite for growth and further comfort.  But to solve even that, the full power of the human mind, with its capacity for looking into the future, is being used.

  9. To want to live only in the present, is to find the burden of human civilization and of enduring delayed gratification, too heavy to bear.

  10. Living in the present is to abdicate the use of some fundamental human faculties, and thereby also some fundamental human anxieties.

  11. The danger of the solution being perpetrated by those advocating "Living in the Present" is this: That instead of marketing it as temporary stress-relief, they are marketing it as a way of life.  We all need unwinding at times when we want to relax and when we don't want to think about the past or worry about the future.  But to never want to be "wound up" is an unrealistic expectation encouraged by self-help teachers.

  12. In other words: To want to live in the present is to want to be on vacation forever.

  13. It is to offer someone a cognitive relief from a problem, rather than to help him solve his problem.  While being high on cocaine, one is oblivious of a looming bankruptcy.  But oblivion is not a restructured loan.

  14. It is true that the constant cognitive and civilizational stress in many advanced human societies might be too much to bear for a large number of human beings.  But to want to live in the present is to admit total defeat.  Much more reasonable would be to adjust one's emotional involvement in stressful pursuits (and to accept the thereby lower rewards) and to undertake a calming/detaching practice a few times a day.

  15. Spiritualists talk in absolutes.  And that is why they are so dangerous.  They ask you not to modulate, but to "let go", to "surrender", to "live through the heart", to "live in the moment", etc.  Modulation advice ("see if you would benefit from moving to the suburbs") sounds less glamorous, authoritative and divine.

  16. Stress, and sorrow and suffering and regret and fear and worry, are to be managed, not to become "free of".  To want to live a stress-free life is to misunderstand life.  It is a desire to go back to the womb (now only couched in more divine terms: nirvana, timelessness, etc.).  To be born is to implicitly accept the burden of life: of competition, of heartbreak, of an uncertain future, of an imperfect past, of mortality, of worry, of losing, of shame, of ridicule, of jealousy, of randomness...

  17. To want to live in the present is perhaps a symptom of not having meaningful goals beyond oneself.  And for that, the whole momentum of the last two hundred years of rationality, breakdown of the community and of religion, is partly responsible.  We are lost in the absence of given meanings, and to create our own is easiest when the meaning is here-and-now, not in the past or in the future.

  18. Religion is not about living in the present, spirituality is.  Religion can be best understood as a code of ethics with a divine authority figure.  Spirituality is less about meaning and ethics, and more about "me", "my feelings" and of "living from the heart".  In other words, religion (though fake) creates a meaning beyond oneself while spirituality (while also fake) aims to make one feel good.

  19. Living in the Present is about "me", and little else.  It is the unending focus on "me" which creates the lack of meaning, and which creates the need for a solution as spurious as living in the present.

  20. It may be cliched, but to find happiness within yourself, try to focus on something other than either happiness or yourself.

  21. Spiritualists will ask you to go "deeper" into yourself.  Beware.

Saturday, August 03, 2013

Some Interesting Quotes about Time, with brief commentary

The present moment is filled with joy and happiness. If you are attentive, you will see it. (Thich Nhat Hanh)

Spiritual aphorisms with an "if" activity prescribed are notoriously hard to refute.  Because if you don't see it, maybe you are not paying enough attention.  Or the right kind of attention.  Or maybe your attention is actually concentration (Krishnamurti was fond of this response).  The real reason why attentiveness dissolves the underlying emotional state to some extent is quite simple: when you begin to be attentive, you are already less invested in that emotional state.  Then you might be more interested in, through attentiveness, gaining some mystical insight about "Fear" or "Mind" or in simply getting out of that state.

Asking a hurt person to be attentive and thereby experience joy is a form of attention manipulation.  Any person in pain is very aware of his pain.  Not aware as  a practicing meditator perhaps, but he is conscious of it.  Without this awareness, depressed people would not be able to recognize their depression and go to the doctor or to a psychotherapist.

The spiritual notion of "being attentive", or more in the jargon, "to be mindful" is to actually forget about what caused the problem (say, that you were diagnosed with cancer, or that you remembered your dead child), and to focus instead on what's happening inside.  Disciplines like Goenka Vipassana don't even ask you to look at the mind.  In that discipline, you need to start attending to your body sensations as in whether you are sweating or tingling.  I am not joking.

When you practice such attentiveness for a longish time, you develop a sort of emotional immunity where outside events don't really cause an emotional (or tingling) reaction in you.  Closer to Nirvana, in other words.

Do not dwell in the past, do not dream of the future, concentrate the mind on the present moment. (Buddha)

It is perhaps a good calming practice at 4am, but otherwise rather bad advice for anyone older than four.

The past has no power over the present moment. (Eckhart Tolle)

It is said that when Eckhart Tolle applied for a mortgage, his credit history came up unsatisfactory and he got a much higher APR than J Krishnamurti.  Then he was forced to take back his words and have J Krishnamurit as a co-signer on the application.

Ask yourself what “problem” you have right now, not next year, tomorrow, or five minutes from now. What is wrong with this moment? (Eckhart Tolle)

It is said that when Eckhart Tolle went to the hospital to get treatment for a mild case of flu, he was turned away as he didn't need it.  After all, at THAT MOMENT he wasn't sneezing.

Can we live so completely that there is no tomorrow for thought to think about? Because time is sorrow.  (J Krishnamurti)

J Krishnamurti didn't need to think about tomorrow because he had quite a trust fund to fall back on.  He gave up the mantle of the World Teacher in 1929, but interestingly, didn't quite give up all the land or the money or his rich friends which he had accumulated due to the charisma around his promise.  He advocated people to give up their boring careers and oppressive families but didn't allocate a portion of his trust fund to them.  Some of the influenced young folks managed to become teachers or trustees at his schools and earned a bit of money repeating and discussing Krishnamurti's sayings ad nauseum.

I have realized that the past and future are real illusions, that they exist in the present, which is what there is and all there is. (Alan Watts)

Alan Watts' says something quite remarkable at first glance.  That the present moment is the only one that exists at the present moment.  No wait, that is a tautology.  This is the attitude of an infant who believes that his mother no longer exists because she went out of sight.

If you don't think about the future, you cannot have one. (John Galsworthy)

This is more true than all the preceding quotes put together.