Saturday, August 03, 2013

It was time, part 3

Parts 1 and 2.

The earnest man pondered over the last utterance of the Master.  He wondered, whether success in this world was secondary to a blissful state of mind.

As the bus in which he was traveling passed through a busy market, an billboard caught his attention.  It was an advertisement for a life insurance policy.  The billboard proclaimed: "Your family is happy now.  Guarantee their happiness forever!"

It was then he suddenly realized that worry in the present was the emotional cost of happiness in the future.  That happiness was an effect, a state dependent on feeling safe, well-fed and cared for.  That spiritualists who asked you to be happy regardless, were asking you to steal something for nothing.  They were telling you that the universe was somehow obligated to keep you happy, that happiness was your "natural state", and that any departure from a state of happiness was therefore a step in the wrong direction.

He then wondered, if happiness was the natural state of man, or whether it was suffering.  After a great deal of mental twists and turns, he came to the conclusion that such universal platitudes were for simpletons.  That this was a false choice.  That life was a mixture of both joys and sorrows and anyone who claimed that life was only one was somehow not ready to accept the measure of sorrow that his life contained.

That while other animals had their strengths, a man had only his mind.  And the fundamental quality of mind, which also was its burden, was its ability to remember, foresee and think.  That without these qualities, one would be in "the moment" but not be fully human.

He leaned back in relaxation, having resolved this philosophical conundrum on his own.  The bus was close to his home now.  He was also not a little sad, and knew that he owed his daughter an apology for asking her to live in the present and to not worry.

As he was getting down from the bus, in his self-satisfaction he did not see where he was going and hit his head at the door and immediately cursed out loud.  

That's when he also realized that to be "in the present" meant not just happiness, but unhappiness as well.  That the state of an infant wasn't a happy state, it was more like a mindless state.  A man who committed suicide because he felt, at that moment, that life was worthless, was living in that moment.  Or rather, dying in that moment.

It was time to put all these thoughts behind him, as he saw the smiling faces of his wife and daughter at his home.  He lifted his giggling daughter into his arms, and whispered into her ear:

"Papa has a present for you.  Your future."

Friday, August 02, 2013

It was time, part 2

Part 1 here.

The master went to his room and started preparing some notes for the next day's talk.

There was a knock on his door and an earnest looking man came in.  The master impatiently waved him to sit down on the floor.  The man said that he had a question.  The master nodded.

The man said: "I have a daughter who followed your instructions and started focusing only on the present.  She stopped worrying about the school exam which was many months away.  Without that worry, she wasn't motivated enough to study.  Yesterday her results came out and she had failed.  Isn't it wrong to not worry about the future?"

The master said, "What I said there wasn't meant to be taken literally.  Of course you can be happy in the present but you must plan for the future with an equanimous mind."

The man said: "But if the future contains possibilities which are unwholesome, aren't worry and fear natural responses to those possibilities?  What's wrong with fear and worry?  Also, if the past contains an experience which we want to avoid, isn't regret and its hurtful memory a way, not a guaranteed way, but at least an emotional effort, for us to avoid coming across it again?"

The master was quiet for a while.  He again tried to ward off the query, "People want to forget their pains when they come to listen to me.  My lectures are for people who are too taken up with the past or the with the future.  They are not for people like you who understand the value of past experiences and future possibilities."

...

The window in the room opened to a garden outside.  It was evening and the gardeners were leaving for the day.  All of them had to carry a heavy burden of their tools and the cut grass which they then sold as fodder for cows and buffaloes.

A few of them were frail and could not carry their individual burden.  The others carried those un-carried burdens in the spirit of either help or resentment.

A child lives in the present.  But its parents cannot.

The master's food was being prepared in the kitchen.  The vegetables being cooked had been sown many months back by the gardeners and had been harvested only a week back.

...

The man was perplexed: "How will a simple person know whether his worry is too much or if it is justified?"

The master became stern faced and said: "Nirvana is the only truth.  Rest is all becoming and preparation for that leap.  If a man falters in this world but lives in the present, he is the God of existence.  Tell your daughter, that even if she failed in the exam, she passed in the eyes of the Universe."

The man left.  It was time for the last bus to his home.

It was time

The Master held his head high and proclaimed in a thunderous voice:

"To avert misery, you must live in the present.  The past is gone, and the future not yet here.  The present moment is all there is.  There is no point regretting the past and fearing the future.  Be happy in the present moment."

At his feet, people deposited currency notes designed to last ten years, and whose decreasing value over time was the headline in that day's paper.  That paper was being used to wrap flower offerings because the flowers wouldn't last long, exposed to the heat.

In the other room, his disciples were busy sending invitations for the next week's meeting in the neighboring city.

Outside the building, some gaunt workers were busy widening the road and were looking forward to getting rest at home in the evening.  The road was planned long back but only recently the municipality had received enough funds to start the construction.

A few miles away, grain in gunny bags were being stored in large warehouses to last till the next harvest.

In the capital city of that state, about a hundred miles away, a college professor was busy writing the second chapter of his book on time series analysis.  He anticipated there to be twelve chapters in total.

Far away in the mountains, many thousands of miles away, an activist organization was busy convincing the illiterate village folk that some newly discovered vaccines might cause discomfort for a few days, but they protected from a host of diseases for the rest of one's life.

In a busy Starbucks cafe on the Wall Street in New York, bond traders were communicating with each other about currency futures and how 2008 must never happen again.

And many millions of miles away, the Voyager 1 spacecraft, launched from planet Earth in 1977, was close to entering interstellar space and was still expected to preserve the "Golden Record" of our civilization.

Meanwhile, the Master's discourse had ended.  As it was time.

The State and its Citizens

If citizens are not allowed to harm each other, then the responsibility of justice, punishment, prevention of crime, forceful resistance to disorder, are the moral responsibility of the state.

If guns are taken away from the citizens, then those guns must point at any aggressor who threatens to harm the now defenseless citizen.

The citizen gives up a lot of power in a modern state.  In return, the state promises him something.  This contract must continue to uphold if the citizen is to have faith in the state.  The alternative is a citizen having scant regard for law, and a state which has scant regard for its citizens.

I believe that in India, this contract between the state and its citizenry has broken down.  In the absence of this contract, what we have is the appearance of democracy, justice and rights.  If we take away this thin veil of high-sounding words, what we have is a plutocracy or dynastic rule in India.

The constitution, and the various laws, prescribe what the citizens and the state must do.  The citizens pay taxes, they agree to not indulge in acts which the state thinks are criminal, they agree to hand over the power of defining personal relationships, property rights, penalties for offenses, how their taxes are used, to the state.  By any reasonable measure, a large majority of people in a modern democracy have absolutely no say in these "state subjects".

The state decrees that you may not marry two people at the same time.  Even if all three are ready and willing.

The state decrees that you may not buy someone's property without paying a percentage (fixed by the state) to the state.

The state decrees that the value of legal tender will be fixed by it, in measures opaque or semi-opaque.  Or that the value of legal tender is only the state responsibility to replace it with legal tender of lesser denomination.

These are rather strong liberties that a citizen gives up.  And there is no exception to these laws.  If you indulge in bigamy, buy property without paying taxes, or try to print currency at home, there will be consequences.

These consequences continue to exist in India.  When a citizen violates the charter, the state comes after him sooner or later.  Or at least he lives in the fear of the state.

So, a citizen then expects the state to fulfill some duties in exchange for giving up these rights.  Whatever those duties might be is immaterial.  The first premise is that the state be answerable to the citizen if those duties are not fulfilled.

The citizen is answerable to the state via the police and the judiciary.  The state must be similarly answerable to the citizenry via the police and the judiciary.  Hence, the police and the judiciary must be, by design, independent of the influence of the state executive, if not also the state legislature.

The judiciary in India was designed to have autonomy, and to some extent it does.  But the judiciary can only provide words.  The judiciary does not possess guns to enforce its orders.  The responsibility of enforcing the orders of an independent judiciary lies, unfortunately, with state-controlled police in India.

I have noticed in hundreds of cases that the court expresses its "displeasure" at some act of the government.  That it passes an order and then wails about its non-enforcement.

In a rather dramatic incident, the prime accused in the assassination of Chief Minister Beant Singh, Mr Balwant Singh Rajoana, was sentenced to death by hanging by a court of law.  The date for hanging was set.

The jail warden refused to comply with the court order.  The court sent him a contempt notice and set another date.  Interestingly, the accused wanted to be hanged and did not want to plead for mercy.  Apprehending a political fallout of this situation, the government filed an appeal on the prisoner's behalf.

I don't think such an incident has happened anywhere else in the world.  The government was the one which prosecuted him, and the government now wants to be merciful on him.

But much more interesting is the conduct of the jail warden.  He wanted to please his political masters rather than follow the order of the judiciary.  He was not afraid of the contempt notice, but he was obviously afraid of going against his bosses.

Once I was privy to a certain conversation in a judge's chamber in India.   It was related to a property dispute where the plaintiff wanted the judge to pass an order of rent collection.  The judge said, and I quote: "It is easy for me to pass the order.  The difficulty is for you to get that order enforced and to get the rent in your pocket. You don't understand how things work.  Better settle it out of court."

So, for all practical purposes, even in with the supposedly independent judiciary, the citizen has to rely on the police for enforcement of law and order.

This is where the situation has not changed in India since the time the British left.  Now we have an elected government, but that government continues to be unaccountable for its failure to keep its side of the state-citizen contract.  It will be unaccountable as long as the police department is designed to be in the service of the state, instead of its citizens.

The constitution can contain any number of laws, the citizen will remain a begging slave of the state as long as he has little recourse when he sees injustice happen.  The state has no incentive to take away its own control of the police.  The only opportunity for that was when the constitution was framed in 1940s.  Now, after indirectly (through the police) giving guns only to the state, it is no wonder that the state of India is not interested in giving power back to the citizens.

The citizens are not fools.  They recognize this remarkable state of affairs.  They know that they have, at least in theory, the power to choose their state representatives.  But if they do not agree with the amount of power these representatives wield, what should they do?  Become Naxalites, perhaps?

In the absence of a working contract between the citizen and the state, not only will there be corruption, but corruption becomes the only valid process of getting things done.  If there are no laws, then discretion, favors, dynasty, quid-pro-quo, become the incentives in a community.

The citizens spit at the laws because they know that they get little in return for following the laws.  That only an idealist should follow laws in a lawless land.  That in such a land, as long as one can get away with bending laws to one's advantage, it becomes not only customary, but a selfish duty.

To be otherwise is to affirm kinship with the Struthio camelus (*).

* Struthio Camelus: The Ostrich.

Thursday, August 01, 2013

You May not Approach the Indian Police

In India, the right of a citizen to approach the police for help is not yet established by the constitution.

If you, or anybody else, is the victim of a crime in India, the first step to get help is to register an FIR (First Information Report) with the police.  After almost one and a half century of the introduction of the Indian Penal Code, this "registration" of one's complaint is still not an unequivocal right of a citizen of India.

Never mind that a mere registration of a complaint is no guarantee of investigation, prosecution or conviction.  In the vast majority of complaints, no investigation worth its name happens.  Some prepared statements are taken from a few people, and presented in court for lawyers to argue for or against.

Despite numerous judgments by the various high courts, there is this "extremely important" question, which was the subject of a judgment in the case of Lalita Kumari vs Govt.Of U.P.& Ors. on 27 February, 2012 (Supreme Court of India):
"7. The short, but extremely important issue which arises in this petition is whether under Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Code, a police officer is bound to register an FIR when a cognizable offence is made out or he has some latitude of conducting some kind of preliminary enquiry before registering the FIR."
And after recording the varied opinions culled from a century of denying Indians the right to effective law enforcement, this was the substance of the judgment:
"112. In view of the divergent opinions in a large number of cases decided by this Court, it has become extremely important to have a clear enunciation of law and adjudication by a larger Bench of this Court for the benefit of all concerned - the courts, the investigating agencies and the citizens. 
113. Consequently, we request Hon'ble the Chief Justice to refer these matters to a Constitution Bench of at least five Judges of this Court for an authoritative judgment."
After glancing through the great wall of text that is this judgment, the following caught my eye:
"51. The fact that Sections 154 (3), 156(3), 190, 202 etc. clearly provide for remedies to a person aggrieved by refusal on the part of the SHO to register an FIR, clearly show that the statute contemplates that in certain circumstances the SHO can decline to register an FIR."
The blame for the suffering of Indians, as it relates to a feeling of helplessness to approach the police, is squarely to be placed upon the architects of our constitution.  On one hand, they prescribe a statutory duty for the police to register the complaint of a citizen:
"(1) Every information relating to the commission of a cognizable offence, if given orally to an officer in charge of a police station, shall be reduced to writing by him or under his direction, and be read over to the informant; and every such information, whether given in writing or reduced to writing as aforesaid, shall be signed by the person giving it, and the substance thereof shall be entered in a book to be kept by such officer in such form as the State Government may prescribe in this behalf." (Section 154, CrPC)
On the other hand, they provide remedies in case this "writing" doesn't happen without penalty to the policeman who refused his duty.  I am simply amazed that this simple act of writing down a citizen's complaint is still the subject of a debate in the highest court of the land.

Moreover, this is an elementary and flagrant misunderstanding of how incentives work in humankind.  If there is a duty or a guarantee, it must be enforced by a mechanism.  If there is no mechanism to enforce it, then the duty or the guarantee is not worth the piece of paper it is written on.

It is similar to someone claiming: "Satisfaction guaranteed."  That is an unfinished sentence.  The complete sentence must say: "Satisfaction guaranteed OR xxx."  And the "xxx" must be of a similar intensity of the initial consideration or promise.

On one instance the Indian constitution and the various laws and acts say something pretty much unequivocal.  Then soon after, sometimes on the same page, they wink at you.  Pliss to unnerstand.

Want another example from recent times?  After the infamous Delhi gangrape case, the following has been recommended as an amendment to the Criminal Procedure Code in India:
“166A. Whoever, being a public servant,––
...
(c) fails to record any information given to him under sub-section (1) of section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 and in particular in relation to cognizable offence punishable under section 354, section 354A, section 354B, section 354C, sub-section (2) of section 354D, section 376, section 376A, section 376B, section 376C, section 376D or section 376E,"
shall be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year or with fine or with both.”.
Attentive readers will note that this excellent provision is logically of the form of:
  • Every x in S has property P (Every reported cognizable crime must be registered)
  • In particular: x1, x2, x3 (Especially the crimes against women)
What is the wink here?  Not a terribly opaque one, I think.

What the lawmakers are saying is: The police must help everybody.  But we know that's not happening, and will not happen.  So they must at least help the women.

So, in the very process of lawmaking, we admit to ourselves that our system is broken and we triage even before we have a calamity.

My question to the lawmakers would be this: If the first part of a sentence of law is assumed to be breakable without consequence, what is the guarantee that anything which comes later is held to any higher standard?  Just because of the words "and in particular"?  Doesn't inspire much confidence.

According to this gentleman, mandatory registration of citizen's complaints can be an infringement of the accused's rights because the police will just go arrest anybody who is accused.  I disagree.  That knee-jerk reaction of the police is to be contained, and must be subject to judicial review.  No court in India asks the police their reasons for arresting any person merely named in a complaint.  Therefore the police currently, to its great advantage, doesn't need to have any.  It's a sorry state of affairs, but it needn't be this way.

The Supreme Court of India has long established in Joginder Kumar vs State of UP (1994) that the power to arrest is not the same, not by a long shot, as the justification for an arrest.  The former is a power, the second is an exercise of that power based on some reasons.  But that judgment, like many more, is gathering dust while the citizens suffer.

It is not true that the police must arrest, and therefore deprive someone of his liberty, as soon as someone complains against someone else.  To avoid this misapplication of police powers, is it justified to snatch the power of the citizens to even approach the police and to register their complaint?  Of course not.

And what is the current status of this issue?  After all a constitution bench was supposed to look at it.

Last I heard, it was still to get a hearing.

Meanwhile alternate means of justice continue to flourish in India.  Connections, Approach, Bribes, "Settlements", Lynch mobs, Community Boycotts, "Rasta Roko", self-immolation in front of police stations, ...