Sunday, October 12, 2008

Mother Teresa

Ms Agnes Bojaxhiu, better known as Mother Teresa, needs no introduction. But her epitaph would be more informed if some excerpts from Christopher Hitchens' The Missionary Position were to be included.

... I began the project of judging Mother Teresa's reputation by her actions and words rather than her actions and words by her reputation.

For just one example, Ms Bojaxhiu's charitable organization was the recipient of 1.25 million dollars (of other people's money) in charity from a convicted fraudster, Charles Keating. She wrote a letter to the judge presiding over his trial, and I quote:
I do not know anything about Mr. Charles Keating's work or his business or the matters you are dealing with.

I only know that he has always been kind and generous to God's poor, and always ready to help whenever there was a need.

...

Whenever someone asks me to speak to a judge, I always tell them the same thing. I ask them to pray, to look into their heart, and to do what Jesus would do in that circumstance. And this is what I am asking of you, your Honor.

The reply from one of the prosecutors is perhaps more interesting:

You urge Judge Ito to look into his heart - as he sentences Charles Keating - and do what Jesus would do. I submit the same challenge to you. Ask yourself what Jesus would do if he were given the fruits of a crime; what Jesus would do if he were in possession of money that had been stolen; what Jesus would do if he were being exploited by a thief to ease his conscience?

I submit that Jesus would promptly and unhesitatingly return the stolen property to its rightful owners. You should do the same. You have been given money by Mr. Keating that he has been convicted of stealing by fraud. Do not permit him the `indulgence' he desires. Do not keep the money. Return it to those who worked for it and earned it!

If you contact me I will put you in direct contact with the rightful owners of the property now in your possession.

Ms Bojaxhiu did not reply to this or return the money.

Another excerpt sheds light on the way her organization refused strong analgesics to terminally ill patients:

She described a person who was in the last agonies of cancer and suffering unbearable pain. With a smile, Mother Teresa told the camera what she told this terminal patient: `You are suffering like Christ on the cross. So Jesus must be kissing you.' Unconscious of the account to which this irony might be charged, she then told of the sufferer's reply: `Then please tell him to stop kissing me.' There are many people in the direst need and pain who have had cause to wish, in their own extremity, that Mother Teresa was less free with her own metaphysical caresses and a little more attentive to actual suffering.


On a side note, Raghu Rai, a noted photographer from India has eulogized Mother Teresa in a photo-book named Mère Teresa (Mère means Mother in Italian) with enough pictures of her wizened face, and her reputed humility and compassion, though it is an interesting question as to why a humble person would allow her humility to be marketed in photo books.


A picture may say a thousand words, but sometimes, a researched footnote is infinitely more useful than a long poem.


(Mother Teresa holding hands with one of the most corrupt women of the twentieth century, Michele Duvalier. Mother Teresa received the Legion of Honor for her visit. She never denounced the Duvalier regime or its corruption and atrocities, or returned the award.)

Thursday, October 09, 2008

On Mr Neale Donald Walsch

Mr Walsch is the author of the "Conversations with God" book series. Many of my relatives find his books enlightening and full of insights about human nature.


I find it strange and inexplicable that such blatant charlatans are eulogized by otherwise sensible people because they offer soothing explanations and feel-good prescriptions for living a moral life.

In his "Conversations with God" series, Mr Walsch purportedly listens to God talking about various subjects. And it is not metaphorical or a literary device, Mr Walsch claims that he genuinely listens to God speaking in plain English.

On his website, he offers the subscription of a mailing list, and offers to join him in various expensive "retreats".

A suitable example is here. Complete with offers of staggered payment plans and whatnot, ...

Admittedly, he is no more of a charlatan than, say, Deepak Chopra or Yogi Bhajan, but the sheer blatant-ness of his marketing left me gasping.

Sunday, October 05, 2008

Le Sang des bêtes (Blood of the Beasts) by Georges Franju

An almost unbearable poem contrasting the banal by nature and the banal by habit, on the iron curtain between horror and civilization that exists in everyday life, this is a meditation on Man, and not a treatise on the innards of his fellow creatures.


Who says concentration camps weren't there in 1949 (when this film was made), or aren't there today?

Desolation in India

There is a quality of silence in lifeless desolation, where a sense of the primeval in nature makes one a part of this universe, rather than the center of it.

One of the biggest drawbacks of city life is the absence of absences. In a city, desolation is nowhere to be found, untrammeled beauty is impossible to imagine, and solitude becomes a retreat rather than an expanse.

 

In desolation, there is no noise, there are only sounds. And there is no dirt, only soil. In nature the colors always blend well, no matter how different or incongruous, ..., the jarring notes occur only in human habitations.

We just finished a marvelous trip to one of the most desolate regions in India: the Spiti Valley at the Indo-Tibetan border.

 

Starting from our home in Chandigarh, we traveled to Manali, and from there, we proceeded to the so-called headquarters of the Spiti region: the town of Kaza.

Our plans to explore the villages around Kaza came to naught because of the unseasonal snow which plunged the entire region into stasis. It took us ten days to finally leave Kaza and get back to Manali, and the many deaths of heedless trekkers and incidents of frostbite were sobering reminders of human limits.

 

But we did manage to visit Kibber, have a trek or two, and see the astonishingly situated monastery at Ki.

 

I have come to the conclusion that people who live in sparsely populated regions are gentler, kinder and happier. They have a quality which can only be called innocence. They still laugh at nothing, have smiles on their faces in the morning, and are generous despite their relative poverty. In the villages of Rajasthan, in the villages near the Great Basin National Park in US, and in the mountains of Himachal Pradesh, innocence survives.

Thursday, October 02, 2008

Elippathayam (Rat Trap) by Adoor Gopalakrishnan



A great film about the various responses to life: inaction, escape, rebellion and suffering. Each of these responses is expressed by different characters in the film. The film is a marvelous portrait of the village life in Kerala. The performances, and the music, are consistently remarkable.

The film makes one uncomfortable precisely because one knows that what one is condemning on-screen is not far from what one has been guilty of oneself at times: Avoidance of Reality.